In today’s PC World, the question is SSD vs HDD boot time. 10 years back, people were not aware of the benefits of SSD. Also the price difference between a HDD and SSD was too high.
In 2019, OEM manufacturers of both PC and laptop have included SSD as an OS booting device. HDD serves the purpose of a storage device. In this way you can optimize both speed and price.
Since Windows 10 takes a maximum of 40GB storage for its system, program, desktop, personalization etc files and folders, a 120GB SSD disk is enough to save costs. This will not only improve boot times, but also program and apps performance.
In the below case-study, we will see the results of my tests conducted using SSD disks. A legacy computer configuration with Intel Core 2 Duo processor and 8GB DDR3 RAM and NVIDIA GeForce 210 graphics card were used.
You will be astonished at the results. If you want to find out how much time it takes to boot up in Windows 10 and Windows 7, keep reading on.
Note: If the boot results with Core 2 Duo CPU are so blazing fast, then you can imagine how your computer will boot up using 8th or 9th generation i3, i5, i7 processors.
Boot Time Testing Software
I used the BootRacer from Greatis Software to test the boot times. The latest version of 7.70 was used in the test for both Windows 7 and Win 10 versions.
This tiny software is very easy to install. You just have to click a few buttons to know the boot time. There are two options. 1. Full boot time 2. Clean boot time.
Once you click the “New Test” button, the computer will restart and will measure the boot time from BIOS start up. There are 4 stages in boot process according to BootRacer software.
2. Windows Boot
3. Password Timeout
Primarily (2) and (4) are considered in calculation of boot time. The other options are neglected. Windows Boot is the time taken to load system resources, drivers, services, logon display etc. Desktop is the boot time required for startup programs, preparing desktop etc.
The following test setup is used to see the boot time performance improvement using SSD.
- Windows 10 Pro 64-bit
- Intel Core 2 Duo E7500 @ 2.93GHz 49 °C Wolfdale 45nm Technology
- 8.00GB Dual-Channel DDR3 @ 533MHz (7-7-7-20)
- Gigabyte Technology Co. Ltd. G41MT-S2P (Socket 775) 46 °C
- P225HQ (1920×1080@60Hz)
- 1024MB NVIDIA GeForce 210 (ASUStek Computer Inc) 56 °C
- 74GB Seagate ST380211AS ATA Device (SATA ) 45 °C
- 111GB Western Digital WDC WDS120G2G0A-00JH30 ATA Device (SATA (SSD)) 46 °C
- 223GB Western Digital WDC WDS240G2G0A-00JH30 ATA Device (SATA (SSD)) 44 °C
- 1397GB Seagate Expansion SCSI Disk Device (USB (SATA) ) 37 °C
- 28GB Kingston DT microDuo 3.0 USB Device (USB )
- No optical disk drives detected
- High Definition Audio Device
Windows 10 64 Bit 1903 version
The latest OS Build of 18362.239 was used to test the boot times. Several iterations were done to test the efficiecy of SSD. As an average Windows 10 took only 35 seconds to boot from BIOS start up.
The Windows Boot Time took 10s and Desktop Boot time was 24s.
This is far quicker than using a HDD. Earlier I installed Windows 10 on a 74GB Seagate ST380211AS ATA Device. The boot time was 3-5 minutes.
I disabled all the startup programs except Greenshot, OneDrive, Windows Security. But the amount of time required to initialize the desktop was more than 5 minutes, when using a HDD.
In another check, the 1809 version booted up more quickly than 1903 version, using a SSD. Though I could not check the boot times using HDD and 1809 version, it is clear that SSD with October 2018 update had the fastest boot time.
Windows 7 64 Bit
The latest OS Build of 7601 was used to check the boot time using a SSD. Service Pack 1 was installed. As of July 2019, all the KB updates were installed.
The Windows Boot time took around 18s and Desktop Boot time was approximately 6s.
The start up programs included Greenshot, Microsoft Security Essentials, OneDrive. In this Windows OS version also both the full boot time and clean boot time were checked.
To my surprise, Windows 7 boot time was between 20 to 25 seconds. Greenshot took the major part of 1.138s. Still the total start up time of all the 3 programs was only 2.137s.
The desktop initialization and start up programs were quick to respond. Even OneDrive and MSE were fast enough to work with. Menus and Programs were quick to open and close. There was no lag or delay in program response.
Windows 10 vs Windows 7 Boot Time Comparison : Using SSD
Im my experience, I observed drastic improvement in boot times after using SSD in both Windows 7 and Windows 10.
I used 64 bit versions for both.
My old Phenom II X6 1045T system, with standard SATA Samsung 860 EVO went from a minute or two boot time on HDD to like 10 seconds boot time on SSD.
My new HP bargain basement laptop that I upgraded with an HP EX920 NVMe SSD (NVMe/PCIe is much faster than SATA) is now basically instant-on (under 3 seconds to boot). Prior it was probably 30 seconds to a minute with the cheap 5400 RPM HDD it came standard with.
Source : quora.com
Though slight improvement was observed in Windows 7 boot times in the SSD vs HDD comparison, further program operations were quick enough after using SSD.
The major boot time improvement can be seen in Windows 10 after using a SSD. As mentioned before, the boot times have come down from 3 minutes to 35s, with HDD and SSD respectively.
Another interesting fact, was that, Windows 7 booted up more quickly than Windows 10. I used the same computer configuration for both the OS, except that Windows 7 was installed on a 120GB SSD and Windows 10 on 250GB SSD.
I used Western Digital SSD for installing both Windows 10 and 7. The models were also the same, except the capacity.
It can be said that using an SSD and Windows 7 will quickly boot up your computer in 2019. But as we know that its support is ending Jan 2020, so Microsoft is deliberate on pushing Windows 10 as an upgrade.
But not to worry!
Even Windows 10 on a SSD was quick enough. Though the difference was only 10 to 15s in boot times, the desktop, drivers, programs, services etc were quick to initialize compared to using an HDD.